华西口腔医学杂志

• 临床研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同浓度含氟牙膏对正畸牙龋病与脱矿的预防效果

华咏梅1,陈  捷1,Jean Gong2   

  1. 1.同济大学口腔医院  正畸科,上海 200072;2.哥伦比亚大学牙科和口腔外科学院,美国  纽约
  • 收稿日期:2006-04-25 修回日期:2006-04-25 出版日期:2006-04-20 发布日期:2006-04-20
  • 通讯作者: 华咏梅, Tel:021-51229117
  • 作者简介:华咏梅(1966-),女,湖北人,副主任医师,学士

The Preventive Effectiveness in Reducing Tooth Decay and Decalcification of Different Concentration of Fluoride Toothpaste for Orthodontic Patients

 HUA Yong-mei1,CHEN Jie1, JEAN Gong2   

  1. 1. Dept. of Orthodontics, Tongji University, School of Stomatology, Shanghai 200072, China; 2. Columbia Uniuversity, School of Dental and Oral Surgery, New York, USA
  • Received:2006-04-25 Revised:2006-04-25 Online:2006-04-20 Published:2006-04-20

摘要:

目的  比较不同浓度含氟牙膏对正畸牙龋病与脱矿的预防效果。方法  将86例采用固定矫治器正畸治疗的患者随机分为试验1组和试验2组。试验1组使用含1.1%氟化钠的酸性磷酸凝胶牙膏刷牙,试验2组使用含0.243%氟化钠的二氧化硅牙膏刷牙,连续使用12个月后,由4个检查者在盲法条件下独立地检查患者12颗上下颌前牙唇面的患龋和脱矿情况,记录龋患得分。有龋或脱矿记分为1,无龋和脱矿记分为0。每个牙齿的4次检查记分取均值,每组患者的得分为组内患者的平均得分。结果  12个月后,试验1组患者的龋患得分为0.326,试验2组患者的龋患得分为0.490,二者之间的差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。结论  含1.1%氟化钠的酸性磷酸凝胶牙膏预防正畸牙龋病和脱矿的临床效果要优于含0.243%氟化钠的二氧化硅牙膏。

关键词: 氟, 正畸, 龋, 脱矿, 牙膏

Abstract:

Objective  To investigate the preventive effectiveness in reducing tooth decay and decalcification of different concentration of fluoride toothpaste for orthodontic patients. Methods  86 patients were divided into the first test group and the second test group. The patients of the first test group brushed tooth with 1.1% sodium fluoride and acidulated phosphate gel. The patients of the second test group brushed tooth with 0.243% sodium fluoride in a silica base. The extent of facial tooth decay and decalcification of the twelve upper and lower teeth from right cuspid to left cuspid was scored blindly and independently by four observers after 12 months of product use. The scores were rated either one(having tooth cavity/decalcification) or zero(no tooth cavity/decalcification). Four observer's readings were averaged per tooth, and then per patient for the two treatment groups. Results  After 12 months of product use, the mean caries score of the first test group was 0.326, and the mean caries score of the second test group was 0.490. There was significant difference between them. Conclusion  A gel system containing 1.1% sodium fluoride and acidulated phosphate provides a clinically better efficacy in reducing tooth decay and decalcification than does a toothpaste containing 0.243% sodium fluoride in a silica base under and adjacent to orthodontic brackets used in orthodontic therapy.

Key words: fluoride, orthodontic, toothdecay, decalcification, toothpaste